Headline A/B Tester
Compare 2-5 headlines side-by-side. Scores each across 7 factors and picks the winner.
Related Tools
How to Use
- Enter 2-5 Headlines — Type your headline options in the input fields. You start with 3 fields — click "+ Add Headline" for up to 5 total. Remove any headline with its × button (at least 2 always remain).
- Click Compare — Each headline is scored across 7 factors: word count, character length, power words, emotional words, uncommon words, question format, and number presence. Scores are out of 100 with a letter grade (A+ to F).
- Pick the Winner — The highest-scoring headline is highlighted as the winner, or a tie is reported when headlines score the same. Cards keep the letter you entered each headline under and show its rank and detailed breakdown, so you can see exactly why one scored higher. Copy the results for your records.
About the Headline A/B Tester
The Headline A/B Tester puts two to five headline drafts through the same 100-point checklist and ranks them side by side. Bloggers, editors, newsletter writers and marketers use it to shortlist options before publishing or before running a real test with live traffic. Each card shows the score, a letter grade and the points earned on every factor, so you can see what separates the drafts.
How the 100 points are awarded
| Factor | Max | Rule |
|---|---|---|
| Word count | 15 | 15 for 6–12 words; 10 for 4–5 or 13–15; 5 for 2–3 or 16+; 0 for a single word |
| Character length | 15 | 15 for 40–65 characters; 10 for 20–39 or 66–80; 3 otherwise |
| Power words | 20 | 8 points per word from a list of 30 (such as proven, secret, ultimate, essential), capped at 20 |
| Emotional words | 15 | 8 points per word from a list of 30 (such as love, fear, amazing, inspired), capped at 15 |
| Uncommon words | 15 | 15 × the share of words longer than three letters that are not on an 81-word list of everyday words or on either list above |
| Question | 10 | The headline contains a question mark |
| Number | 10 | The headline contains a digit |
Grades: A+ 85 and above, A 75–84, B+ 65–74, B 55–64, C+ 45–54, C 35–44, D 25–34, F below 25. Headlines with the same score share a rank, and the banner reports a tie rather than picking a winner. Words are counted between spaces; an emoji counts as one character.
Worked example
| Headline | Score | Grade |
|---|---|---|
| Shocking Secret: Why Do Insane Writers Love Lists? | 72 | B+ |
| 7 Proven Ways to Improve Your Writing Today | 57 | B |
| The Ultimate Guide to Content Writing in 2026 | 54 | C+ |
| Seven Proven Ways to Improve Your Writing Today | 47 | C+ |
| How to Write Better Content for Your Blog | 38 | C |
All five earn full marks for length. The top headline wins on surface features: three power words (shocking, secret, insane) for 20 points, one emotional word, and a question mark. Writing “Seven” instead of “7” costs 10 points, because only digits count as numbers. “How to Write Better Content for Your Blog” reads like a question but has no question mark, so it gets nothing for that factor.
What the score cannot tell you
- It is a checklist, not a forecast. The points reflect common copywriting conventions, not click data from your audience, so a higher score does not mean more clicks.
- It does not read for meaning. Accuracy, clarity and whether the headline matches the article are not checked, and stacking list words raises the score even when the result reads like clickbait, as the example shows.
- The word lists are English. Headlines in other languages can only score on length, questions and numbers, plus the uncommon-word factor.
- “A/B” here means side by side. No live experiment is run. A real A/B test splits actual readers between versions, through tools such as an email platform’s subject-line test or an ad platform’s experiments.
Practical tips
- Use the breakdown to spot what a draft lacks (no number, too long, no concrete words) rather than to choose blindly. If you add a power word, make sure the article delivers on it.
- Check length where the headline will appear. Google sets no limit on title length but truncates title links to fit the device width (Google Search Central, checked on 2026-10-14), so put the important words first. The Character Counter helps you trim.
- Shortlist two strong drafts here, then test them with real readers if you have the traffic.
- For a deeper look at one headline, use the Headline Analyzer; for writing advice, read How to Write Better Headlines.
Privacy: the scoring lists are part of the page’s JavaScript, so your headline drafts are scored in your browser and never sent anywhere.
Frequently Asked Questions
How is each headline scored?
Seven weighted factors: Word Count (15 pts — ideal 6-12 words), Character Length (15 pts — ideal 40-65 chars for Google), Power Words (20 pts — words like "proven", "essential", "ultimate"), Emotional Words (15 pts — words that trigger feelings), Uncommon Words (15 pts — percentage of non-common vocabulary), Question Format (10 pts — headlines with "?" get a bonus), Numbers (10 pts — headlines with digits like "7 Ways" or "Top 10"). Total: 100 points.
What are power words?
Power words are persuasive words that trigger a psychological response. The tool checks for 30 power words including: proven, secret, ultimate, essential, exclusive, powerful, instant, guaranteed, remarkable, surprising, shocking, incredible, breakthrough, revolutionary, massive, brilliant, genius, and stunning. Each power word found adds 8 points up to a maximum of 20.
What is the ideal headline length?
There is no single ideal. This tool gives full points for 6-12 words and 40-65 characters, a range many editors use as a rule of thumb. Google does not set a length limit for titles, but it truncates title links in search results as needed to fit the device width, so the most important words should come first. Very short headlines can lack context, and very long ones risk being cut off.
How is this different from the Headline Analyzer?
Our separate Headline Analyzer tool (at /tools/headline-analyzer) scores ONE headline at a time with its own weighting, an emotional word ratio, and platform length checks. This A/B Tester lets you enter 2-5 headlines and compare them SIDE BY SIDE with one consistent 7-factor scoring system. It ranks them, highlights the winner (or reports a tie), and shows detailed breakdowns so you can see exactly why one headline beats another. Use it to pick the best option from multiple drafts.
What do the letter grades mean?
A+ (85-100): Exceptional headline with strong power words, ideal length, and engaging format. A (75-84): Very strong. B+ (65-74): Good with room for improvement. B (55-64): Decent. C+ (45-54): Below average. C (35-44): Weak. D (25-34): Poor. F (under 25): Needs complete rewrite.
Is this tool connected to any service?
No. All scoring uses client-side JavaScript with built-in word databases. Your headlines are never sent to any server. The power word, emotional word, and common word lists are embedded in the code.